Lit.Org - a community for readers and writers Advanced Search

Average Rating

(3 votes)

RatingRated by

You must login to vote

I have recently read that assisted suicides have been increasing dramatically in the state of Washington, where they were legalized in 2000. In 2002, there were 88 assisted suicides. The physicians of these people made some determinations about long-term physical and mental health, the possibilities of recovery and suffering, counseled them regarding their true desire to die, and then dispensed legalized lethal drugs.

While the Supreme Court of the United States has upheld the law in Washington, I doubt that this phenomenon is going to spread throughout the country. Iím certain weíll never see it appear in the Deep South states, and Iím reasonably certain it will never take hold in Pennsylvania, my home state. The Pacific Northwest, which includes Washington, has always been very left-of-center (why am I not there?!), while the Deep South and many other Eastern states such as Pennsylvania are unfortunately often the strongholds of right-wing opinion.

Yet Iím still disturbed, however strongly I support freedom of choice, by the appearance of legalized assisted suicide in Washington. I supported the concept during the rampage of Dr. Jack Kevorkian, prior to his imprisonment, but now that large numbers of people are Ďopting outí, all in one locality, I worry. What if a large number of states ratified such a law? How many people across the land would Ďopt outí?

I can only say what most people would likely say: time will tell whether many state legislatures legalize assisted suicide. What I do know and fear, should this occur, is that many, many people will take this legal opportunity to find an easy Ďexití from what might be an impossibly difficult or painful life but is still a human life.

Like abortion, this is surely going to be an eternally debated issue, with never an end in sight for legal argument and political wrangling. It will simply never end. Politicians will drag this one out like a bloody shirt to wave in front of voters, whichever side they take, just as is happening even now in the state of Washington. There, groups assembled against the standing law continually protest against it and have been dragging the fight to Congress to gain an upper hand in their efforts to strike it down. As I mentioned, though, it hasnít worked.

Iím grateful that the Left can still defeat Republinazis on some issues. Still, I wonder Ė

Might the right wing be right about this particular issue?

Most of those people will say that God has spoken through their literalist interpretations, and that God says they are right. My own Roman Catholic church, while not fundamentalist, says so too. But what of my own opinion and my reverence for the freedom-to-choose?

Again, I say: time will tell. If this becomes a holocaust, with the lambs going into the slaughter voluntarily, I might have to side with the right wing on this one.

Legalized assisted suicide, except in the worst medical cases, might simply be too much to allow in any society.

The Alienist

Related Items


The following comments are for "Quandaries of Legalized Assisted Suicide"
by The Alienist

cut-off points.
An interesting article.

The problem I have with this issue is one of boundaries.

By legalising it, the state has moved the cut-off point of what is acceptable.

There will always be Dr. Kevorkians in this world, and they delight in pushing the boundaries. And for every Dr. Kevorkian, there are others who do the same but hide their actions.

You can only move the boundaries so far before it gets dangerous, and I believe that legalising assisted suicide did exactly that.

Moving the boundaries simply means that the next Dr Death will be advocating euthenasia instead (and I fully suspect that some of the assisted suicides taking place already are in fact disguised euthenasia).

This boundaries point is the same for many if not most of the really controversial issues today: Legalise pot, change the age of consent, or the age of drinking; all you do is move the cut-off point. And the pressure will remain just as intense to move it again.

( Posted by: Spudley [Member] On: March 14, 2003 )

piece, again. In the UK, assisted suicides are still illegal, as are successful suicides by ones own hand (quite how THAT works out, Gawd only knows.) But, don't we have the right to do as we wish with our own lives?

( Posted by: ogg [Member] On: September 1, 2003 )

Add Your Comment

You Must be a member to post comments and ratings. If you are NOT already a member, signup now it only takes a few seconds!

All Fields are required

Commenting Guidelines:
  • All comments must be about the writing. Non-related comments will be deleted.
  • Flaming, derogatory or messages attacking other members well be deleted.
  • Adult/Sexual comments or messages will be deleted.
  • All subjects MUST be PG. No cursing in subjects.
  • All comments must follow the sites posting guidelines.
The purpose of commenting on Lit.Org is to help writers improve their writing. Please post constructive feedback to help the author improve their work.