Lit.Org - a community for readers and writers Advanced Search

Average Rating

(0 votes)

You must login to vote

From everything I've seen and read recently about Todd Haynes, the director and co-writer of the new Bob Dylan bio-pic, “I’m Not There,” he’s an extremely intelligent, honest, creative, sensitive, and ambitious filmmaker with only the noblest intentions. Imagine coming up with the concept of casting six different actors to star as Bob Dylan’s many sided personality. It’s positively Dylan-esque. But there’s only one problem with “I’m Not There” – it doesn’t work.

No it doesn’t work - and what a shame. “I’m Not There” had so much going for it. Bob Dylan has steadfastly refused to authorize the rights for a big screen biography. Todd Haynes was able to convince him with his ingenious concept for the film. Once Dylan signed on, Haynes gathered an amazingly eclectic group of talented actors to play the roles:

Marcus Carl Franklin as Woody (Guthrie)
Ben Whishaw as Arthur (Rimbaud)
Christian Bale as Jack and John (protest singer and pastor)
Heath Ledger as Jack (the actor)
Richard Gere as Billy the Kid
Cate Blanchett as Jude

“I’m Not There” breaks fast out of the gate with lots of sound and exciting images. Marcus Carl Franklin is wonderful in the first part of the film as an eleven year old hobo riding the rails of late 1930’s America in search of his personal musical vision. But it’s not long before the movie begins to veer wildly out of control. With no real plot to hang a story on, “I’m Not There” turns into a collage of seemingly unrelated story lines, flashbacks, flash-forwards, and good old fashion confusion. I believe even the most sophisticated Dylanologist will be perturbed.

It’s the performance of the lovely Cate Blanchett that lends the film it’s only true piece of real credibility. Blanchett is literally transformed into an almost uncanny identical twin of the Bob Dylan from the mid-sixties (thin as a string bean with shocked crazed hair). Shot in black and white, the Cate Blanchett scenes range from remarkable subtleness to over the top zaniness. In fact, the only time one truly senses Dylan’s presence in the movie is when Blanchett is on the screen.

Unfortunately, some of the scenes in “I’m Not There” are almost embarrassing - for instance - a clumsy reenactment of Dylan’s appearance on the Steve Allen show could have easily been deleted. The scene in which Dylan accepts the Tom Paine Award from the Emergency Civil Liberties Committee is breathtakingly bad. And an inordinate amount of time is spent on Dylan’s conversion to Christianity, which, in my opinion, is a particularly insignificant period in his career (a bewildered looking Christian Bale portrays Dylan in all these scenes).

At 2 hours and 15 minutes in length, "I'm Not There" eventually grows tedious. The tedium was almost palatable in the small audience I was a member of at the beautiful Arc Light Theater near Sunset and Vine in Hollywood.

I suggest taking another look at the classic D.A. Pennebaker documentary “Don’t Look Back,” or Martin Scorsese’s monumental “No Direction Home.” I have a greater appreciation for both these films having seen “I’m Not There.”

I applaud Mr. Haynes for his effort, but, regrettably, “I’m Not There” truly lives up to its title.

Related Items


The following comments are for "I'm Not There - a review."
by johnjohndoe

a simplistic viewpoint
I thought this movie was excellent. I don't think it was made to inform as much as to bombard the viewer with rich imagery, symbolism, and the message of course: "I'm Not There." The emphasis on Dylan's flirtation with Christianity is no less than the one on the whole Pat Garrett theme, but still, he's not there. I came away with the feeling that throughout all the transformations and alter egos, he is still becoming something else; no matter what label or ideology you hang on him, he has moved on since then. Thus, all the funerals for his alter-egos.

As for "No Direction Home," who can argure with the beauty of it all?

( Posted by: brickhouse [Member] On: October 9, 2010 )

..not there
I enjoyed your review.

"I'm glad I'm not me." - Bob Dylan

( Posted by: Bobby7L [Member] On: October 9, 2010 )

Add Your Comment

You Must be a member to post comments and ratings. If you are NOT already a member, signup now it only takes a few seconds!

All Fields are required

Commenting Guidelines:
  • All comments must be about the writing. Non-related comments will be deleted.
  • Flaming, derogatory or messages attacking other members well be deleted.
  • Adult/Sexual comments or messages will be deleted.
  • All subjects MUST be PG. No cursing in subjects.
  • All comments must follow the sites posting guidelines.
The purpose of commenting on Lit.Org is to help writers improve their writing. Please post constructive feedback to help the author improve their work.