Lit.Org - a community for readers and writers Advanced Search

Average Rating

(0 votes)

You must login to vote

Review: ‘CSA: Confederate States of America’ (five of five stars)

The ‘mockumentary’ or ‘fictional documentary’ is not a new form. Its most famous example has been the infamous ‘The Spinal Tap’ (1982), detailing the travels and travails of goofball British heavy metal act Spinal Tap. The fictional rock band existed in the flesh, yet, releasing two albums and going out on tour like a real band. The suspension of disbelief despite the obvious comic delivery is legendary.
The attempt by the same participants to reuse the formula for a ‘folkie’ band, ‘A Mighty Wind’, was not so successful.
Nonetheless, when an effective director and creative team puts imagination and a wealth of knowledge and talent into a project, especially with a sense of mission, the result is serious suspension of disbelief, and at a time when alternate ‘what if?’ histories of a Confederate victory in the US Civil War (1881-1865) are flourishing, this movie is a phenomenon whose time has come.
Made with the help of the British Broadcasting Corporation and African-American film director Spike Lee, ‘CSA’ has received widespread attention as a re-examination of American History in an increasingly popular focus: what would’ve happened if the South had won the Civil War? What would America be like right now?
Using vignettes, television commercials, interviews, narrated footage, ‘Hollywood’ movies, silent pictures and even reality show trailers, ‘CSA’ possesses the full flavor of an historical documentary while expecting the audience to accept what they see as a document on an existing entity: a Confederate States of America circa 2006. While filmed low-budget, the film’s dark sense of humor and frightening contrasts are believable, based on real historical research of actual historical facts and events as well as known plans and attitudes of the Confederacy’s leaders.
As an individual fascinated by alternate histories and with US Civil War history, this writer found ‘CSA’ to be a thoroughly worthwhile comparison and contrast between that other world and this one,, intellectually forcing the question “Is America truly significantly different in important ways from what it might have been if the South had won?”
Whether the viewer sits at Left or Right from Center, or dead in the middle, ‘CSA’ is a fascinating and enlightening look at the possibilities that were left mysteries by the currents and eddies of Time. Watching the black-and-white interview of Abe Lincoln, an exile in Canada in 1912 confessing that “Now I, too, am a Negro” helps enflesh this otherworld with conviction and creative detail that the viewer will appreciate throughout the film.
This writer is an educator who will use the film with his eleventh-grade students in conjunction with material relating to 19th-century US literature,, and he expects it to be highly successful in demonstrating the importance of the events and figures of that time to their own lives and surroundings.
It should be equally educational to adults who want to understand the truth of the soul of the American Nation: it is dark, but potentially could be yet darker.
The DVD copy at hand came from Spain, the only place at this writing where home copies of the film are being (legally) produced. It was purchased from a New Jersey import vendor via eBay after thorough searching. The film is presently being shown in selected independent theaters and other venues across the United States. The Spanish DVD edition does have an English-language track (the native track, although the Spanish-language track is the default) and the DVD is Region 2.

The Alienist

Related Items


The following comments are for "CSA: Confederate States of America (DVD/Theatrical Release)"
by The Alienist

Whether the south had won or not, whether we elect republicans or democrats, and whether the average audience pays attention or not, I believe that somethings should not be studied and presented to the masses, espicially high school students, that might "explain" the real truth about why the world is in the state it is. Things that happened in the past probably had some effect on the future, but those happening were likely "random" at best.

Even if a person knows the perfect truth, it is probably better to work dilligently to lobby politicians, social organizations, and committees to effect positive change than it is to spill the beans for profit.

Exposing corruption does nothing to correct it. Now, if the "what if" scenario you mention is only for entertainment value (which sounds like the case) then it probably does not deserve or warrant such in-depth analysis that the "I too am a Negro" comment (et al) is anything more than given for affect to a specific situation in time. That comment does not mean today what it meant then.

Anytime a writer, actor, director, professor presents American history to foreign audiences it must be presented as a meaningful course of discovery -- that most astonishing or noteworthy occurrences of the past were probably rather mundane events that have only grown new fur over the years. The facts that were facts when 1st occurrences took place have long been forgotten, and replace with newer facts that better fit with our perception of our own history.

Every civilization throughout history has done the same. "Atilla the Hun was a superb leader who once held audience with the Pope..."

Anyway, good writing and some though provoking information.


( Posted by: BWOz [Member] On: April 23, 2006 )

Add Your Comment

You Must be a member to post comments and ratings. If you are NOT already a member, signup now it only takes a few seconds!

All Fields are required

Commenting Guidelines:
  • All comments must be about the writing. Non-related comments will be deleted.
  • Flaming, derogatory or messages attacking other members well be deleted.
  • Adult/Sexual comments or messages will be deleted.
  • All subjects MUST be PG. No cursing in subjects.
  • All comments must follow the sites posting guidelines.
The purpose of commenting on Lit.Org is to help writers improve their writing. Please post constructive feedback to help the author improve their work.