Lit.Org - a community for readers and writers Advanced Search
 




Average Rating
0.00

(0 votes)

You must login to vote

GIVING GOOD CRITICISMS and HOW TO HANDLE CRITICISMS


‘Animals are such agreeable friends—they ask no questions, they pass no criticisms,” ~George Eliot

I LOVE CRITICISMS! I always loved to wake up in the morning with my Yahoo inbox filled with Vorpal messages because Lit.Org members read my literary posts and commented on them. Call me impractical, but I don’t usually turn a window straight on to Lit.Org. I follow certain rituals. I open a site through my Yahoo inbox, like Christmas morning presents I open the messages one by one, patiently checking each item for the name of whoever commented.

Each word of praise props me up and spurs me on to write some more with equal beauty and quality. Every negative comment, however, registers in my mind and challenges me more to improve the piece being criticized, or to write some more with what I believe a better content to offer.

I love critics, and every bone in their heads (first quoted by Eugene O’Neill)! I also started to love giving criticisms, bad and good. I realized at how good critics of movies and plays could give straightforward, sometimes even offensive criticisms. I believe they help; and in literary criticism, an honest opinion, comment or review should always be appreciated as one would the creative writing.

Before writing down your review or opinion, think that what you shall do is an attempt to evaluate and understand the literature of an author. There are questions that one may ask when writing criticisms: What has the author attempted to do? How has he done it? What do I think of his effort? You must first find your approach to a literary work depending upon your point of emphasis. Should you be tackling the relationship between the work and the author? Should you be discussing the form, style or art? There are also matters that can be considered, those beyond the art form itself—like its relevance to society or man, lessons or the feelings it evolved. Study the work thoroughly and wholeheartedly and you may be able to judge it in the light of what you think the author has set out to accomplish. Start off by saying something good if you reckon your following words could not be avoided to be harsh. At the end, reaffirm your support and confidence in the person.

Now, there are still some more questions that a critic may base upon his comment. Like “What does the work say?” Sometimes there is more to a piece of writing than meets the eye. “What does it mean? Does the piece succeeded to impart to the reader its message, or does it really hide its meaning?” A literary work can be abstract and therefore requiring a subjective rather than an objective reaction (I believe that abstract must still have a subject—otherwise it is just a nonsense crap!) “How does it communicate and how well does it communicate? Most of all---is it worthwhile?” It is what most writers are emotional about their writing—whether it’s worthwhile or not. Critic does not necessarily present all the answers to all these questions; he simply uses these as guide to his thinking and then selects a much narrower topic on which to write.

“There are three reasons I comment. I comment when I am moved either by content or talent, I comment when I feel that my opposing view, or some constructive criticism might paint a clearer picture or help the writer and/or the reader, and I sometimes comment just because I like something which doesn’t meet the other two criteria. That is not to mean that I think that I have better ideas or even skills, but sometimes, another perspective can shed some light to both the reader and the writer, which will help both.

”We all need input. To live in a vacuum or on a mountaintop does not fulfill our purpose. We can all preach from the mountain, we can all ignore the world and just stay in our own little universes. But to have any impact on the world, on our fellow men, we have to come down from both. We don’t fulfill our purpose by remaining isolated. So my time at lit is one of the ways that I try to find the interaction that makes me better, that educates and enhances me, and I hope, helps to encourage others to keep on keepin’ on....No one wants the brick wall where their work is concerned. So, to comment (good or bad) on it, is to encourage, enlighten, or enhance that which is already planted, and sometimes just to go OH YEAH!” –Claire Robinson (Clairesbest), EXPOSED!



HOW TO HANDLE CRITICISMS

Consider criticism part of the process of submitting your work to Lit.Org. This will help you forget about the emotional reaction to being criticized. Put in your perspective that criticisms, all of them, are positive because they help you become better and do better. A successful man is one who can lay a firm foundation with the bricks that others throw at him. Be glad that someone cared to read your post and commented on it, because it is an effort made!

You can learn more about how to improve in your writings through criticism than through many other channels, like what Penelope Allen once said in her Exposed! Interview by Clairesbest: “I think that is crap. What is important is to be observant and to think about things on more than one level. To consider the opinion of others. To be wide open in the receptive capacity. To swallow stars and spit out pearls.” Penelope considers the idea that the best and most enduring artists are those who have experienced pain and suffering is not true.

Also remember that being misunderstood is possible. It is inevitable that your intentions will be misconstrued. A criticism helps you prove yourself and regain the respect you deserve.

When someone criticizes your work, turn off your ego and (crank up) your objectivity. You may defend yourself but do not let it interfere with the learning opportunity. Remember that no matter how valid your self-defense, it comes off as a sign of insecurity, weakness and even unwillingness to perfect your craft. Apply your defense to understanding what your critic is telling you.

“Critics may not be agreeable friends, because they are not animals—they think, they ask, they are human and their feet are but made of clay and they touch ground,” well, this is an adage I invented, you may think it is funny but if you will only reflect on it, you will know that I am making sense.



-END OF NEWBIES SERIES-


RECOMMENDED READINGS:

*The recent WRITE-OFFS
*The Light Thread
*A Gypsy Poet-Artist's Villanelle





------
*************************************
crystal face I kiss
tongue tastes like sweet cold rain
I fall into pond




Related Items

Comments

The following comments are for "NEWBIES! Tips Ahoy (Part 3)"
by Peterpaulino

Even beter peter
The writing quality in this piece exceeds the others, the material is wonderful as well. Such wise and caring thoughts on your subject. may everyone of us take what we need and grow from it. thank you Peter, again, huni..

( Posted by: huni [Member] On: August 21, 2004 )

Peter's tips
Great Job Peter. I look forward to all of your tips. You are sooo good! Oh and I like that recommended reading, Gypsie Poet ;0), wonderful.
Thank you for taking the time to write these.

Nae

( Posted by: nae411 [Member] On: August 21, 2004 )

stupid n00bs.
Critiquing is oftentimes helpful for the critic as well as the recipient. It is easier to find mistakes in other people's work than your own, I've found, so by offering criticism you are helping yourself develop a critical eye which your writing will benefit from. Nicely written article, Peter.

( Posted by: die_daily [Member] On: August 21, 2004 )

tips ahoy
Another good one, Peter. I sure do appreciate the time and effort you put into your articles, and poetry. You're awesome!

( Posted by: mzjen1 [Member] On: August 22, 2004 )

Huni, Nae, DD, Jen
Thank you very much for commenting!

Huni, I'll take your word that this one's better, Gypsy!

Nae, and your approval is what I always look forward to!

Die_Daily, LOL you scared me with the title and then I LOL!

Jen, Gypsy Mom, you too are awesome!

( Posted by: peterpaulino [Member] On: August 22, 2004 )

Tina, Lucie, Pen
Tina, Namaste! Thank you for your uplifting comment. I strived hard to make this one better and it's for all of us. It will make me remember always what's necessary and essential if I'll be back again commenting to people's work (the way I was doing before) Too bad I still don't have my own computer. But once I come back I promise to attend to other writings here.

Lucie, reading and commenting on members' literary works has become a passion for me, and your extensive and sincere practice of doing the same is what inspired me. People always value your comments and anything that you would have to say about their works, I know that, because that's just how I feel. Thank you and for your effort in reading everything I write and commenting on them.

Penelope, my comrade! Thanks God you liked that adage I formulated LOL. I am trying to imitate your honesty and sincerity in commenting to people's works. I agree with you that that particular quote you had in Claire's Exposed! is very much quotable and has a strong impact. Thank you for allowing me to use it and I know it will continually be useful to this part of my Newbies whenever someone will read it.

( Posted by: peterpaulino [Member] On: August 23, 2004 )

Great
Great piece Peter.

( Posted by: nimashirali [Member] On: August 27, 2004 )

Nimashirali
Thank you for taking your time. I welcome you to the other parts of this. See you there...;D

( Posted by: peterpaulino [Member] On: August 27, 2004 )





Add Your Comment

You Must be a member to post comments and ratings. If you are NOT already a member, signup now it only takes a few seconds!

All Fields are required

Commenting Guidelines:
  • All comments must be about the writing. Non-related comments will be deleted.
  • Flaming, derogatory or messages attacking other members well be deleted.
  • Adult/Sexual comments or messages will be deleted.
  • All subjects MUST be PG. No cursing in subjects.
  • All comments must follow the sites posting guidelines.
The purpose of commenting on Lit.Org is to help writers improve their writing. Please post constructive feedback to help the author improve their work.


Username:
Password:
Subject:
Comment:





Login:
Password: